/in , /by

💡 Deductibles Explained: How They Actually Work (And Why They Matter More Than You Think)

When it comes to insurance, “deductible” is one of those terms everyone has heard… but not everyone truly understands. 
And the truth is—your deductible can make a HUGE difference in how much you pay both monthly and when something goes wrong.

Let’s break it all down in a simple, real-world way so you actually feel confident about your coverage

🧾 What Is a Deductible?

A deductible is the amount of money you pay out of pocket before your insurance kicks in.

👉 Think of it like your “share” of the risk.

Example:

  • You have a $1,000 deductible
  • Your claim is $5,000
  • You pay $1,000
  • Insurance pays the remaining $4,000

Simple, right?

🔍 How Deductibles Actually Work (Real-Life Scenarios)

Car Accident Example

Let’s say you rear-end someone (it happens):

  • Damage to your car: $3,500
  • Your deductible: $500

👉 You pay: $500
👉 Insurance pays: $3,000

🏡 Home Insurance Example

A storm rolls through Northwest Indiana and damages your roof:

  • Repair cost: $12,000
  • Deductible: $2,000

👉 You pay: $2,000
👉 Insurance pays: $10,000

⚠️ Important Note:

You only pay a deductible when:

  • You file a claim on your own policy
  • The loss is covered

If someone else is 100% at fault?  Their insurance should pay (no deductible for you)

📊 Types of Deductibles You Should Know

Not all deductibles are created equal

1. 💵 Fixed Dollar Deductible

  • Most common (ex: $500, $1,000, $2,500)
  • Easy to understand and predictable

2. 📈 Percentage Deductible (Common for Home Insurance)

  • Based on your home’s insured value

Example:

  • Home insured for $300,000
  • 2% deductible = $6,000 out of pocket 

👉 This is HUGE and often surprises people

3. 🌪️ Special Deductibles (Storm/Wind/Hail)

  • Separate deductibles for specific risks
  • Very common in Indiana due to weather

👉 You might have:

  • $1,000 standard deductible
  • BUT $5,000 wind/hail deductible

💰 Deductible vs Premium: The Trade-Off

Here’s where strategy comes in

Deductible Monthly Premium Out-of-Pocket Risk
LOW ($250–$500) Higher Lower risk
HIGH ($1,000–$5,000+) Lower Higher risk

👉 The Rule:

  • Higher deductible = lower monthly payment
  • Lower deductible = higher monthly payment

🤔 So… Which Deductible Should You Choose?

It depends on YOU

Choose a HIGHER deductible if:

✔️ You want to save money monthly
✔️ You have emergency savings
✔️ You don’t file small claims often

Choose a LOWER deductible if:

✔️ You prefer predictable costs
✔️ You don’t want big out-of-pocket surprises
✔️ You want peace of mind

🚨 Common Deductible Mistakes (Avoid These!)

❌ 1. Choosing the cheapest policy without checking the deductible

That low price might come with a $5,000+ deductible

❌ 2. Not knowing you have a percentage deductible

This is one of the BIGGEST homeowner surprises

❌ 3. Filing small claims

If your deductible is $1,000 and damage is $1,200…
👉 You’re only getting $200—and risking higher premiums later

❌ 4. Having a deductible you can’t afford

If you can’t comfortably pay it, it’s too high. Period.

🧠 Pro Tips from an Independent Agent

As an independent agency, we see this all the time

✨ Bundle policies (home + auto) to offset a lower deductible cost
✨ Review your deductible yearly—your situation changes
✨ Match your deductible to your savings
✨ Ask about claim-free discounts before filing small claims

📍 Why This Matters (Especially in Northwest Indiana)

Living in the 219 region means dealing with:

  • Strong storms
  • Snow/ice damage
  • Wind & hail claims

👉 Which means your deductible isn’t just a number—it’s what you’ll actually pay when things go wrong

🏁 Final Takeaway

Your deductible is one of the most important parts of your policy—not just a small detail.

👉 It affects:

  • Your monthly payment
  • Your financial risk
  • Your overall coverage strategy

The goal isn’t just “cheap insurance” … it’s smart protection.

 

 

You can experience being a part of and full-serviced independent Insurance Agency today! Simply contact Briggs Agency Inc, if you are interested in an insurance review at 219-769-4840 or visit our website at www.BriggsAgency.com. We look forward to hearing from you!

 

Blog post written by: Zachary Pelke